What Should Each Apartment Pay?


Property developers taking on their first apartment block will be confronted with the question: What should each apartment contribute to the overall strata budget?

The apartment building you are planning to develop may be made up of 10 apartments, of varying shapes and sizes, and overall the strata needs $50,000 each year to pay for the expenses like insurance, lifts, cleaning, maintenance, electricity and capital replacement.  How should the $50,000 of expense be shared?

One view is that all apartments are in the same building so all the owners should contribute equally – $5,000.   Nice and simple.  However, this view is flawed because not all apartments cause the same amount of expense.  For instance, a penthouse owner goes further in the lift each day, and so causes more lift expense.  The penthouse apartment is bigger and requires more paint.

Another view may be that bigger apartments cost more to maintain so they should pay more based on the size of each apartment.  Should a 120 m2 apartment pay twice the amount of a 60 m2 apartment? Again, this approach seems simple and fair.  However, the size of each apartment does not have a relationship to the amount of gardening costs.  The garden is the same size and costs the same amount, no matter how big the apartment.  All owners benefit equally from having manicured gardens and lawns.

Or should more expensive apartments pay more than the affordable apartments?  Is it fair that people who buy $1m apartments pay twice the strata levies of people who buy $500,000 apartments?  Ability to pay is not the same as being the cause of the expense.

These decisions about what each owner should contribute are not easy but making these decisions is part of the process of going to market with your development.  It can be a contentious decision, and failing to apply the guiding principles correctly can cause problems later on, which is all the more reason to seek the advice of your strata manager.

The guiding principles your strata manager will use do vary from state to state, and the terminology changes in each state, with some of the principles over-lapping .  It would be ideal if one day our state governments could get together and make some uniform land laws for all strata schemes in every state.  In the meantime we need to battle on with each state going its own way.

The best analogy for what each apartment owner should pay to the overall strata budget is to consider the strata scheme to be like a company, with each apartment owner being like a shareholder in the company.  Each share (or apartment) is given a weighting which determines the proportional amount which each owner needs to pay towards the common funds held by the strata scheme.  The weighting given to each apartment may be called the contribution entitlement, the interest entitlement, the lot liability, or the units of entitlement – it all depends upon the state you are doing the development in.  The weighting will not only determine how much of the total you pay, but also may be the weight which your vote will carry when the common decisions are made at a general meeting of the owners.  The weighting will be calculated by balancing all the competing principles.

Here a simplified example

Your strata manager will help you balance all the factors and help you determine the weightings.

Here is a snapshot of some of the states:

Victoria:

In accordance with The Victorian Subdivision Act 1988 and The Owners Corporation Act 2006.

In Victoria the Owners Corporation budget is divided amongst lot owners based on Lot Liability, which is determined by a Land Surveyor when the initial plan of subdivision is being set up. Establishing the number of units of liability for each lot is based on a combination of factors including the size of the apartment and the price the apartment will be sold for off the plan.

NSW:

 In accordance with the NSW Strata Scheme Management Act 1996.

In NSW, units of entitlements are set up by a valuer. This is usually based on an estimate of the market value of each lot at the commencement of the scheme.

If ever there is a requirement for an adjustment of unit entitlements, it can be achieved through an order reallocation of unit entitlements. The basis for a reallocation is on value and a registered valuer must obtain physical access to every lot to determine the back-dated market variation.

Queensland:

In accordance with The Body Corporate Community Management Act 1997

When a body corporate scheme is established, lot entitlements are initially set by the original owner on the advice of the strata manager. There are 2 types of entitlements.  One is the interest entitlement which is based on market value.  The second is the contribution entitlement.  There are 2 principles that the strata manager will generally use to determine the contribution entitlements – either the equality principle or the relativity principle.  These principles are explained in the Body Corporate and Community Management Act.

Western Australia:

In accordance with the Western Australian Titles Act (STA).

In Western Australia, units of entitlement set by a licensed valuer. Under the Strata Titles Act (STA) unit entitlements are used as a means to establish the voting rights, the undivided share of common property and the proportion of contributions levied. Unit entitlements can be changed under certain conditions, i.e. Re-subdivision. Further information can be found in the WA Strata Titles Act 1985 (STA) as amended; and the Strata Titles General Regulations 1996.

South Australia:

In accordance with Strata titles Act 1988.

In South Australia, lot entitlements (unit entitlements) are formula based using capital value and must be certified correct by a licensed valuer. In order for certification to be provided, the unit entitlements must be expressed in whole numbers. The certifier will allow for an allowance of 10% either way. To explain it simply, if your lot is worth more than another in your complex, you will have greater unit entitlement. Further details can be found within the Strata Titles Act

Tasmania:

In accordance with the Strata Titles Act 1998.

In Tasmania all lots have a general unit entitlement which determines the voting rights, proportional ownership of common property and body corporate contributions of each owner. These general unit entitlements apply for all purposes of the Act unless special unit entitlements apply.

Special Unit entitlements take into account differing circumstances, i.e. if a building has a lift that only some of the owners have access to, then that would not fall under common property for all owners and the unit entitlements would vary accordingly.

Under the Act, unit entitlements may be changed at a later stage by a unanimous resolution of the body corporate or by order of the recorder of titles- See part 9 of the Act for further information.



Related post

Who’s Responsible For Pest Control in a Body Corporate
Who’s Responsible For Pest Control In An Owners Corporation
Running A Business in a Body Corporate

Recent Comments

2 Comments

G. A. On February 12, 2017 | Reply

In 2013 I have bought a 2 bedroom apartment, in the block there are 6 apartment with 3 bedrooms and 3 with 2 bedrooms, from what I was told we are paying the same strata levies, I feel that it is unfair due to the bigger value of the bigger apartment. I was told that the bylaw in place I have to pay the same amount. Any suggestions as there change that we pay according of the measures of each apartments?

    SSKB On February 16, 2017 | Reply

    Hi G.A.

    Levies are charged based on each unit’s lot entitlement. Lot entitlements are set up by the developers when the scheme is established and inserted into the CMS. Making any changes to these lot entitlements requires a resolution without dissent at a general meeting.

    Hope this helps!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.